Friday, September 20, 2013

THE MAN WHO HAD EVERYTHING - Steven L. Good

The Wall Street Journal of January 7, 2009 carried a shocking story:

Real-Estate Executive Found Dead in Apparent Suicide

CHICAGO -- Real-estate executive Steven L. Good was found dead of an apparently self-inflicted gunshot wound Monday in his Jaguar in a forest preserve outside Chicago, said the Kane County Sheriff's Department.

Mr. Good, 52 years old, was chief executive of Sheldon Good & Co., one of the nation's largest real-estate auction firms.  His father founded the company in 1965.

In a prepared statement Monday, Sheldon Good President Alan Kravets called it "a testimony to Steve's leadership that Sheldon Good & Co. remains well positioned for the future [and] poised for significant growth."

As chairman of the Realtors Commercial Alliance Committee, Mr. Good said last month in an industry outlook news release that market conditions were "very challenging."

According to the company's Web site, Sheldon Good "has sold more than 45,000 U.S. and international properties in more than 100 different classes and produced more than $10 billion in sales."

Mr. Good wrote a book called "Churches, Jails and Gold Mines...Mega-Deals from a Real Estate Maverick."  In it, Mr. Good tells how he purportedly turned his auction firm into the real-estate equivalent of Sotheby's or Christie's.

"That book is a must-read for anyone in real-estate auctions," said Chris Longly, spokesman for the National Auctioneers Association.

No one was more shocked when they read the story than I was.  You see, I knew Steven Good - we went to Evanston Township High School together - as together as you can with a student population (at that time) of over 6,000 students.  Steven Good would not have been able to pick me out of a lineup, but I knew him - everyone knew Steven Good.  Beyond high school we knew each other professionally but I am getting ahead of myself.  Let's start at the beginning:

Steven Loren Good was born November 16, 1956 to real estate magnate Sheldon Good (b. 1933) and Lois, nee Kroll (1933-1985). Steven was the couple's first child.  He would later be joined by a younger brother, Todd.  

I first encountered Steven when we were both students at Evanston Township High School.  Everyone knew Steven because everyone knew of his father Sheldon Good who pioneered auctions as a way of selling commercial real estate.  Sheldon Good & Company started in 1965, so by the time we were in high school it was a household name to people who lived on the North Shore.

Steven was popular in high school - he was on the tennis team, and student council - and he graduated, as did I, in 1974:

Steven L. Good - 1974

I envied Steven Good back then.  I just assumed that he would be joining his father's firm, and I envied his being able to step right into a top-tier position after college.

Steven went on to earn a bachelor's degree from Syracuse University, and a law degree from DePaul University.  He interned for a U.S. senator, in the U.S. Department of Justice and the Cook County State's Attorney's office.  According to their website, Steven joined his father's firm "in the late 1970s," and that's really when his star began to shine. 

Steven's father, Sheldon Good, revolutionized the commercial real estate industry when, in 1970 he auctioned a chain of fast food stores in downstate Illinois.  Others had tried auctioning commercial real estate with limited success, but Sheldon Good made it work - and made it work big.  Steven joined his father's company just as it began to take off.  In the 1980s and 1990s you could not drive around Chicago without seeing one of Sheldon Good and Company's signs announcing an upcoming real estate auction.  Here's Steven standing next to one of their famous signs:



  
The company expanded, building success upon success and became the nation's premier real estate auctioneer.  As often happens in businesses made up of more than one generation, the younger generation wanted to take the company in a direction the older generation was not ready to pursue.  That was the case with Sheldon and Steven Good.  Sheldon reported that he would retire when he turned 70 (2003) but this was not quick enough for Steven, and so, in 2001 Steven bought out his father's controlling interest in the firm. Sheldon Good would remain on the payroll as Chairman Emeritus, but it was Steven's company to run. Although the name of the company remained Sheldon Good, it was now Steven Good who was calling the shots.

And so, at the age of 45, Steven Good was owner and manager of one of the country's top real estate firms. I continued to envy Steven Good his success.  I was doing well myself, but nowhere near as well as Steven Good.

Looking at the firm from the outside, one could see the picture of a family firm: 71-year-old Sheldon F. Good, chairman emeritus, at his desk and his son Steven L. Good, 47 and CEO of the company his dad built, down the hall. Nearby, some 70 employees making the firm one of the most successful real estate auctioneers in the U.S., selling everything from Aspen trophy homes to mining rights in Montana - no wonder I was envious.


But, it turned out that all was not rosy between the Goods, father and son.  Crain's Chicago Business reported in 2004 that it was a dysfunctional family firm.  The paper said that the two Goods rarely spoke, parties in a bitter court feud stemming from the son's 2001 buyout of the father's controlling stake in the firm, Sheldon Good & Co.  In a lawsuit he filed in October 2002, Sheldon Good accused his son and the firm of a litany of offenses, from denying him commissions to sticking him in a small office.  The other member of the Good family, Todd Good, Steven's younger brother, had already joined and then left the family firm.  He left in 1997 because, as he reported, of a dispute with Steven.

Family troubles did not stop Steven Good, the businessman.  He continued to grow the company, and even wrote a book in 2004, sharing his secrets for success.  The book is called "Churches, Jails and Gold Mines, Mega Deals From a Real Estate Maverick".  One reviewer called the book's thesis, "My company and I are great." Steven was thrilled that he was able to get real estate magnate Donald Trump to write the afterword to the book.



About the time the book came out, Steven Good was interviewed by Dr. Margot Weinstein, a career consultant and real estate expert.  You can still see the interview on Youtube:


Steven was also active professionally.  Among the many positions he held in the industry were Chairman of the Realtors Commercial Alliance Committee and Past President of the Chicago Association of REALTORS®.

While he was slaying dragons in the real estate market, Steven Good was not neglecting his personal life.  He had a beautiful wife, Jami, and three sons:  Scott, Logan, and David.

As the year 2008 ended and 2009 began, it looked to the whole world like Steven Good had it all: He was at the helm of a tremendously successful company; He was respected by colleagues nationwide; He had a beautiful home in Highland Park, Illinois, and a beautiful family.

I have tried very hard with all the stories I have written for this blog, not to judge the people I wrote about or the decisions they made.  So on that morning in January of 2009, we don't know why Steve drove out to the Kane County forest preserves in his Jaguar and ended his own life, but he must have felt that he had no other choice.

Here's Steve's obituary from the Chicago Tribune - January 7, 2009:

Steven L. Good, suddenly died.  His zest for life will be missed by his beloved wife, Jami; loving sons, Scott, Logan and David Good; brother of Todd (Sue) Good; son of Sheldon and the late Lois Good; fond son-in-law of Kay Fasman; dear brother-in-law of Gregg (Renay) Mandell and Jeff (Mary) Mandell.  He will be missed by his many nieces and nephews and all who knew him. Memorial Services Wednesday, 11:30 a.m. at North Shore Congregation Israel, 1185 Sheridan, Glencoe, IL 60022.  In lieu of flowers, memorial contributions may be made to North Shore Congregation Israel.  Arrangements by Chicago Jewish Funerals, 847-229-8822.

Steven is buried in Westlawn Cemetery in Norridge, Illinois:




After Steve's death there were rumblings about financial improprieties, and in fact, Sheldon Good and Company was forced to declare bankruptcy in April of 2009.  What remained of the company was ultimately purchased by Racebrook Marketing Concepts LLC in July of 2009, who continues to use the Sheldon Good & Company name to this day.

I do not envy Steven Good any more. May he rest in peace.

It has been said that the best way to get the true measure of a man is to ask those who work with him.  I'll end this article with some of the comments made about Steven by his colleagues after his tragic death:

He treated me well and served the organization diligently over the years with his enthusiasm, expertise, knowledge, commitment, and financial support.  I rarely saw him without that effervescent smile and a twinkle in his eye.

Steve went out of his way to take an interest in me personally and professionally and made time in his extraordinarily busy schedule for me.  He made a big impact on my career and opened doors for me that otherwise wouldn't have existed.

Steve was truly one of the smartest people that I have known.  He always seemed to be a couple of steps ahead of what everyone else was thinking, and had a knack for looking at things differently and more creatively than anyone else.

I will never forget his bigger than life positive attitude, his incredibly quick wit and his generosity.


Steve was accomplished, generous and astute.  He served as a resource to many within our industry. A brilliant thinker, he usually had the solution to a problem before most knew there was a a problem.

He met challenges head on and mastered the art of problem-solving.  Steve had that ever-present smile that allowed all to "warm up" to this powerful and respected professional.  He had friends across the continent who adored and admired him.  No one worked a room better than Steve - and before he left that room, he made sure he established lifelong friendships.

He was straight to the point and the first to offer a helping hand.  He was generous to a fault.  He gave to our industry, his alma mater, his community and to a host of charities.  He loved the real estate business and poured himself into every opportunity to share his expertise.  His ego could fill a room, but he could also be all about inclusion and consensus.  He found humor in his need for the spotlight, his Inaugural video was as suited for MTV as the September evening we celebrated with him just a few years ago.

There was a purpose to nearly everything he did, and his competitive spirit was memorable in its scope and depth.  Steve had decided long ago he would, to borrow from Daniel Burnham, "make no little plans." He was forever striving for the next goal, the next triumph, the next success.


He was a gentleman.  A positive fellow who would go out of his way to make sure you were doing fine.  He had a inner light that would instantly brighten the mood of any environment.  He cared deeply about the Association and its members.  He stayed active in the industry and particularly in his volunteer efforts at the local and national levels.

Steve was one of the most charismatic people I have ever met and an incredible source of inspiration to so many people.  Steve accomplished more in his one lifetime than some men could in 10 lifetimes.  And, can we ever forget his fabulous smile?

Steve taught me so much and he was a true friend.

Steve Good...there are not enough words to state what a wonderful person he was and the appreciation that I have for being blessed by knowing him.  Steve always had a smile on his face and was always focused on a new business venture for the near future and was very free in sharing his enthusiasm about the projects he was working on.  His enthusiasm was highly contagious.

Whenever I spoke with Steve he would always leave me smiling and had an incredible talent of making me laugh.


Here is a man who always stepped up to the plate.  No matter how big (always better) or small the project Steve was there.  He basked in the limelight.  He loved publicity and looked for every opportunity to promote himself and his company.

I had the pleasure of meeting Steve when I first came to Chicago.  His knowledge and love of his profession and his city was very enthusiastic and catching.  He always had opportunities to offer and advice to share, and was a leader and mentor to many, particularly in his work and dedication to helping others succeed as well.  I valued his guidance and leadership in our commercial alliances and international projects, among many other things.  A room really came to life when Steve walked in.  I learned a lot about many things from knowing him that can never be taken away.  His personality and style were unmatched.

As a leader, Steve inspired others with a "can do" attitude.  His words of encouragement came in the form of phone calls, short notes and brief stops in my office to simply say "hi."  As one who was extremely successful within the industry and life, he encouraged others to join in that success.

Looking back, every conversation with Steve began and ended with a warm smile, a genuine inquiry regarding how things were going on my end of the world and, with every project I was working on, a very real "How can I help?"  Steve's humor, joy, energy and optimism transcended our roles within the organization.  He truly made me feel like I was a partner and not an employee.


Steven L. Good 1956-2009

Friday, September 13, 2013

THE REST OF THE STORY - Jacob Raffsky

Several weeks ago I told the story of Jacob Raffsky, who lies under a unique tree tombstone at Jewish Waldheim Cemetery in Forest Park, Illinois.  To refresh your memory, here are some photos of the tree tombstone:



I mentioned at the time I wrote the article that I was unable to locate the death certificate, but "it is certain he died from one of the myriad of diseases that killed young people at the end of the nineteenth century."

Much to my surprise, a little over one week after I published the story an angel emailed me Jacob Raffsky's death certificate.  It was a Coroner's Death Certificate, and therefore was not indexed like the regular death certificates.  After reading the Coroner's Death Certificate, the story changed significantly.  Here's the certificate:


The cause of death was "From shock and injuries received by being run over by an unknown train belonging to the Chicago and North Western Railway Company on their tracks near Elston Ave Sept 13th 1889." 

Here is a Google Maps photo of the site where the Chicago and Northwestern railroad tracks cross Elston Avenue.  Today, the tracks are elevated above grade; in 1889 they may well have been at street level.


There is another interesting fact buried on the death certificate. Fourteen year old Jacob Raffsky was employed - as a clothing cutter. He was not in school as other fourteen year old boys were, he was already working.  In 1889 there was no requirement to remain in school until the age of sixteen as there is today.  

Once I knew the particulars of the accident I was able to find a mention of it in the Chicago Daily Tribune of September 14, 1889:

At 8:15 o'clock last night a youth about 18 years old was found on the Northwestern Railway tracks near Elston avenue with both legs cut off. He was taken to the county hospital in an unconscious condition and died an hour later.  

I often say that for every question your genealogy research answers, five new questions pop up.  That is certainly the case here:

1.  What was Jacob Raffsky doing on the Northwestern train tracks when he was killed?  Was he trying to hitch a ride?

2.  Was Jacob Raffsky running away from home?  If he was, the Northwestern was a poor choice - it is a commuter train - not a long distance carrier.

3.  Was he alone, or with friends when he was killed?

4.  Could he have been intending to commit suicide?

5.  How long had he been working as a clothing cutter?

We will probably never know the answers to these questions.  They, like Jacob Raffsky, have been lost in the mists of time.

The lesson for researchers here is never assume you know the whole story until you have all the facts. 

So, let's pause for a minute to think of the fourteen year old boy who got too close to a train (intentionally or unintentionally) and paid the consequences one hundred twenty-four years ago today.

May Jacob Raffsky rest in peace.

Friday, September 6, 2013

DEATH AT AGE OF 103 - Isaac Shaffer

I have often told stories in this blog of children who die, either from accident or disease.  This week I thought we'd go to the other end of the spectrum and look at someone who died at the ripe old age of 103 - Isaac Shaffer.

The Chicago Daily Tribune of June 18, 1936 carried the following obituary:


Let's see what we can find out about this man who lived 33 years beyond the biblical "three score and ten". You would think that someone who lived to be over 100 years old would leave a lengthy trail of records, but in this case, just the opposite is true.  It was very hard to find any records for Shaffer or his family.  Let's look first at what I could find:  

According to his death certificate, Isaac Shaffer was born Israel Shaffer on March 10, 1833 in Lutnick, Russia.  His father's name (Anglicized) was Harry Shaffer; mother's name unknown.


The next record I found on Isaac is in 1910 Census.  In 1910, Isaac and his wife "Tailba" lived at 1302 N. Claremont Avenue in Chicago.  They told the census taker that they had been married for forty years, and that they had five children, all of whom were living in 1910.  They indicated that they came to the US in 1902, but in 1910 were naturalized citizens of the US.  Isaac's primary language was Yiddish, although he could speak English - Tailba was limited to Yiddish. Neither of them were working in 1910, but both could read and write, as could most Jews of the era.  Unfortunately, 1302 N. Claremont is now a vacant lot.

Through other sources I was able to find three of their five children:  Lawrence (b. 1882), Sam (b. 1892) and Bessie (b. 1893).

Believe it or not, here's where the trail on Israel/Isaac goes cold.  I checked every possible combination of names and spellings, but could only find the Shaffers in the 1910 Census.  Nothing for 1920 or 1930.

Now let's take a look at the tombstone to see if anything can be learned from that.  The death certificate says Cong. Esras Israel, in Proviso, Illinois.  Esras Israel is one of the gates at Jewish Waldheim - Gate 35. Here is a photo of the tombstone of Isaac and his wife:

  
I had one of my friends translate the Hebrew to see if there were any clues there.  Isaac's says "The important man Isaac (Yitschak) son of Gershon"

His wife's inscription is almost entirely in Hebrew except for "Age 95 Yrs - at Rest."  The translation of the Hebrew for her is: "Toive, daughter of Hillel".  So Toive would be the Taube from the 1910 Census.  I found her death certificate from October 31, 1929 under "Tillie" Schaffer:


When Tillie died in 1929, the Shaffers were still living at 1302 N. Claremont.  By the time Isaac died in 1936, he was living at 1301 N. Campbell in Chicago, which is still standing:

1301 N. Campbell, Chicago

But wait a minute - Israel/Isaac's death certificate says he is widowed but lists his wife as "Sarah" - not Tillie/Toive/Taube.  Did Isaac marry again after Taube's death and outlive the second wife?   I did find a record for an Isaac Shaffer marrying a Sarah Moss but that was in May of 1864, so not the one I am looking for.

One last observation:  people tend to think that if information is listed on an "official" document (birth, marriage, death, census) that it must be correct.  Unfortunately that is not true generally, nor is it true with Isaac and Toive.

Isaac's death certificate lists his date of birth as March 10, 1833, in Lutnick, Russia.  It is very unusual for a Russian Jewish immigrant of that time to know their date of birth so exactly.  In the Jewish shtetls of that era, birth records were not kept, and if a calendar was used at all, it was the Jewish calendar, which does not correspond directly to the Gregorian calendar.  That's why many of these immigrants chose national holidays as their birth dates - they chose a date they could remember. 

We have limited records for Israel/Isaac, but let's see if they line up.

Birth year from death certificate:  1833
Age listed on 1910 Census:  70
Birth year based on 1910 Census:  1840

If Isaac had been born in 1833, he should have told the census taker that he was 77, not 70.

Let's see if Toive's dates line up:

Birth year from death certificate:   1837
Age listed on 1910 Census:  66
Birth year based on 1910 Census:  1844
Age from tombstone:  95

If Toive had been 95 in 1929, her year of birth would have been 1834. In 1910 she should have told the census taker that she was 76, not 66.

Was Isaac Shaffer really 103 when he died in 1936?  Was Toive Shaffer really 95 when she died in 1929? We'll never know for sure, but you can't always believe something just because it is on an "official" document.  You have to weigh each piece of information against the other information you have uncovered.  

Israel Shaffer

Taube Shaffer

May Israel and Taube Shaffer rest in peace.

Friday, August 30, 2013

THE BEST PAVING MAN IN THIS COUNTRY - Louis Fahrberger

When I was doing research for the article on William G. Edens, for whom the Edens Expressway was named, I came upon an interesting notation in one of the documents:

LOUIS FAHRBERGER, General Supt. of Arcole Construction Co., had been their oldest employee and intended to retire after the Edens Highway job was completed.

He started to build a new home in Skokie in which to spend the last years of life, when on June 13, 1951, he was killed by one of the Arcole trucks on Edens Highway near Emerson Street.

A wonderful man, esteemed by all who new him, and was considered the best paving man in this country.

He was born March 7, 1886, and passed away June 13, 1951.

It is not unusual for workmen to be killed working on major construction projects.  Five workers were killed building the Empire State Building, and eleven men were killed building the Golden Gate Bridge.  But those were projects "up in the air" whereas the building of a highway is work done "on the ground."  After reading this, I decided to find out the story of Louis Fahrberger, the only man killed during the building of the Edens Expressway.

Louis Fahrberger was born Alajos Fahrberger on March 7, 1886 in Burg, Hungary, to Francis Fahrberger (1857-1910) and Juliana, nee Fahrberger (1861-1905).  

Louis came to the United States on February 26, 1905, when he was just short of nineteen years old and settled in Chicago.

On August 29, 1908 Louis married Miss Mary Oswald st St. Aloysius Church in Chicago:


and they were blessed with their first child, a daughter Mary, on May 12, 1909.

The 1910 Census shows the young family living at 1532 N. Rockwell in Chicago.  I can't show you where they lived because the building the Fahrbergers lived in was torn down circa 1990 and replaced with a townhouse.  On the census form Louis listed his job as "Cement Worker."  1910 ended on a happy note for the Fahrberger family - their second daughter Josephine (1910-1972) was born on December 6th.

Like many immigrants of that era, the Fahrbergers were anxious to become Americans and they became naturalized American citizens on May 31, 1912.  Later that same year their son Louis (1912-1981) was born on October 1st.

Things had changed for the Fahrberger family by the time the 1920 Census was taken.  The post World War I building boom of the 1920s had not started yet, so Louis listed his occupation as "Car Repair" and the family lived in the rear of 2445 W. North Avenue in Chicago which is still an auto parts store all these years later:

2445 W. North Avenue, Chicago

By the 1930 Census, the fortunes of Louis Fahrberger and his family had improved substantially. They now owned their own home - a bungalow at 5452 W. Byron in Chicago:

5452 W. Byron, Chicago

Louis now listed his occupation as "Superintendent Building a Cement Road".

All was not well for the family when young Mary Fahrberger died suddenly on January 1, 1931 of complications from diabetes:


Even though the country was suffering through the depths of the Great Depression, Louis Fahrberger continued to do well.  By the 1940 Census the family was still living in the bungalow on Byron, but now Louis listed his occupation as "Executive - Construction and Asphalt." Things continued to improve for the Fahrbergers and by the time he registered for the World War II draft on April 27, 1942 Louis listed his address as 6523 N. Tahoma in Chicago:

6523 N. Tahoma, Chicago

He listed his employer as the Midwest Construction and Asphalt Company.

Another happy occasion took place on June 18, 1946 when Josephine Fahrberger married Stanton Frederick Reberg in Chicago.  

Somewhere along the way The Midwest Construction and Asphalt Company became the Arcole Midwest Corporation,


and it was under that name that they became one of the contractors involved with the building of the Edens Superhighway (as it was called then).

Edens Overpass over Cicero Avenue

As mentioned above, Louis Fahrberger planned to retire as soon as the Edens project was done - but he would be going out on top.  The Edens project was a Twenty-three million dollar project, and when it was completed it would be known as the "Most Beautiful Highway in the Country."  Fahrberger was excited to be working on a project of this size and scope - and right here in Chicagoland.  He spent every free minute supervising all aspects of the paving work.  Here he is talking with Alex Mariotti, one of the foremen on the project:


Construction on the Edens Superhighway started in 1946 and the highway was dedicated five years later, on December 20, 1951.  The end of the huge project was in sight when tragedy struck.  From the Chicago Daily Tribune of June 14, 1951:


What happened?  We will never know for sure.  Fahrberger instructed the driver to move the truck and was standing behind it when the driver backed up.  Maybe Fahrberger thought the driver would pull out instead of backing up; the driver surely thought that Fahrberger had gotten out of the way.  I could not find any record of charges being brought against George Will - it seems to have just been an unfortunate accident.  A tragedy for all concerned, but an accident nonetheless.

Here is Louis Fahrberger's obituary from the Chicago Daily Tribune, June 15, 1951:


Louis Fahrberger is buried in St. Joseph Catholic Cemetery in River Grove, Illinois:



He is buried with his wife Mary, his daughter Mary Ann, and his grandson L. Martin -


and with his daughter Josephine, son Louis, and Louis's wife Evelyn.

The next time you are on the Edens Expressway, if you seek the monument of Louis Fahrberger, look around you.

Louis Fahrberger

Louis Fahrberger, said to be the best paving man in this country - may he rest in peace.

And what about George C. Will - the man who was driving the truck that killed Louis Fahrberger?  As I mentioned above, there is no record of any charges being filed against Will - the whole episode was just an unfortunate accident.

Will went on to marry and raise a family - I couldn't find out whether he stayed in the construction trades or not.  Here's his obituary from September 1, 1983:


Finding Will's grave was a different matter.  St. Matthew's Lutheran Cemetery in Niles is tucked away in a residential neighborhood.  It's not too large - maybe six city lots deep by five city lots across.  It has alot of trees, and burials going back to the pioneer days - many of the old tombstones with German inscriptions.


The main wrought iron gates were padlocked, but the side gate was open, so in I went.  It took me two complete passes through the entire cemetery before I found George Will's grave.  His tombstone had been almost completely buried and was under some overgrown evergreens:


I brushed away the dirt and debris and here's the stone:


George C. Will died at the age of 64.  We will never know how he was affected by the accident that caused the death of the beloved Louis Fahrberger.  I would imagine not a day went by that he didn't think about the accident, and he probably replayed that day in his mind thousands of times - wondering why he did what he did.  We can only hope that George C. Will found peace in life and that he is resting in peace today. 

Friday, August 23, 2013

RUDOLPH VALENTINO'S FAITHFUL DOG - Kabar

August 23, 2013 marks the 87th anniversary of the death of silent film superstar Rudolph Valentino who died in New York City on August 23, 1926.  Those of you who are frequent readers of this blog will remember that I have been fascinated with the life and career of Valentino for over forty years.  Every August 23rd since 1927 there has been a memorial service for Valentino at the Hollywood Forever Cemetery (formerly Hollywood Memorial Park Cemetery) in the Cathedral Mausoleum where he is interred.  The service starts precisely at 12:10 PM which is the time Valentino died in New York - although 12:10 New York time would really be 3:10 Los Angeles time.  I attended my first Valentino Memorial Service in the 1980s and for many years I was one of the featured speakers at the service which remembers Valentino as "The Greatest of Them All."

Hundreds of books have been written about the life and career of Rudolph Valentino, so it is not necessary for me to expand on those. However, to remember Valentino on the anniversary of his death I would instead like to tell you the story of his faithful friend and companion:  his Doberman named Kabar.

Kabar

Rudolph Valentino loved animals, but he especially loved horses and dogs.  He was an excellent horseman and did many of his own horse-related stunts for his films, much to the alarm of the studios who were worried that something might happen to their star money-maker.  But as much as Valentino loved his horses, he loved his dogs even more. Some of Valentino's dogs were kept in kennels on his property but certain "special" dogs were given the run of the house.  One of these "special" dogs was Kabar.

Kabar was born June 20, 1922 in the Alsace region of France.  Alsatian Dobermans are said to among the finest in the world - and also the smartest.  When Kabar was just a few months old he was given to Valentino when Valentino was staying at the French estate of the Hudnut family, relatives of his then-wife Natacha Rambova (nee Winifred Shaughnessy).  The donor was said to have been a Belgian diplomat who was also a fan of Valentino.  From the very start, Valentino and Kabar were inseparable, and Kabar was even allowed to sleep in Valentino's room wherever he happened to be.

People who are very wealthy like to have their animals travel with them, and this was the case with Rudolph Valentino.  However, pets of the wealthy are not housed in the baggage compartment, or even in steerage - they are with their owners in First Class.  Here are two great photos of Rudolph Valentino with Kabar on the deck of the Leviathan:



   Here are two photos of Valentino with his family - and Kabar:

L-R:  Jean, Rudy, Ada, Alberto and Kabar

L-R:  Rudy, Jean, Ada, Alberto and Kabar

Here's a photo of Valentino with Sophie Tucker and Kabar:


As you can see, Rudolph Valentino took his dear friend Kabar with him wherever he went.  Here they are at Falcon Lair:


We'll never know why Valentino did not take Kabar with him on his last trip East in July of 1926 - but he didn't.  And then the shocking news of August 23, 1926 from New York:


Several sources reported Kabar's unearthly howling at the time of Valentino's death three thousand miles away.  It has been reported that the howling scared Beatrice Lillie so badly that she ran her car off the road and fainted when driving home from a party at John Gilbert's house.  Anyone who is around dogs becomes very aware that they have some sort of extra-sensory perception, particularly on an emotional level.  Our family beagle howled all night when my grandmother died unexpectedly.  At first we did not connect the two incidents but his howling was so unusual and mournful that we then realized the two were connected.

It was reported that once Kabar started his mournful howling, Valentino's other dogs housed at Falcon Lair joined in the chorus.  No wonder Beatrice Lillie was scared! 

Things seemed to have gotten a little better when Valentino's brother Alberto arrived, but Kabar was almost constantly sick after the death of his beloved master.

There is no cure for a broken heart, and Kabar finally died of grief on January 17, 1929.

Kabar's death was even reported in the Chicago Daily Tribune of February 3, 1929:


From the beginning Alberto realized that his brother and Kabar had a special bond.  Alberto considered burying Kabar somewhere on the grounds of Falcon Lair, but he knew that technically that was not legal in Los Angeles.  The city laws stated that animals could only be buried in a cemetery set aside for that purpose under city grant and approval. That wouldn't do Alberto any good - at that time there were no animal crematories or pet cemeteries in Los Angeles - or so he thought.  Then someone told Alberto about the Los Angeles Pet Park in Calabasas - about 22 miles from the heart of Hollywood.

The L.A. Pet Park was founded by a veterinarian to the stars named Dr. Eugene C. Jones. The cemetery, hidden among lush rolling hills and an industrial park off the Ventura Freeway, was once part of the estate of Hollywood financier Gilbert H. Beesemeyer, who embezzled $8 million from the Guaranty Building and Loan Assn. in 1929. But before his estate crumbled and he went off to begin serving a 40-year sentence at San Quentin, he subdivided his property into several 10-acre plots, one of which Jones purchased.

Jones, who graduated from Washington State College with a degree in veterinary medicine in 1924, moved to Los Angeles, where he opened one of the city's first small-animal hospitals, the E.C. Jones Veterinary Hospital on Santa Monica Boulevard in West Los Angeles. Four years later, as a service to his clients and as a way for them to deal with their bereavement, he opened the Los Angeles Pet Park and a Hollywood pet funeral parlor.

The Los Angeles Pet Park officially opened for business on September 4, 1928, and a mortuary and crematory were added in 1929.

This was the answer that Rudolph Valentino's brother Alberto was looking for.  He could have Kabar buried at the L.A. Pet Park, acknowledging Kabar's special status as a beloved dog of Rudolph Valentino.  The cemetery still mentions in their advertising that Kabar was the first pet of a film idol to rest in the plot near Calabasas.


In November of 1931 Screen Play Magazine did a feature article on the pet cemetery, and of course, Kabar was mentioned.

Screen Play Magazine - November, 1931

I made my first trip to Hollywood and the grave of Rudolph Valentino in 1980.


I was not able to make it to the pet cemetery on my first trip, but several years later I was finally able to make the drive all the way out to Calabasas.


It was a typical Sunday afternoon in the summer in Los Angeles - hot and clear.  The cemetery had grown somewhat since the 1930s photos, but was very well kept, and many of the graves had decorations on them.


The office was unfortunately closed the day I was there, and there was not another living soul in the cemetery.  What if I couldn't find Kabar's grave?  I asked Valentino and Kabar for help, and in a short time I found Kabar:


But now I had another dilemma.  I wanted a photo of me at Kabar's grave, but as I mentioned, there was not another living soul there.  I decided to wander around and see if I could find someone.  After awhile I found a couple who had recently buried their dog at the cemetery and had come to visit his grave.  They graciously agreed to take my photo at Kabar's grave:


I will end with a quote that I feel sums up the special relationship between Rudolph Valentino and his beloved Kabar:

The one absolutely unselfish friend that man can have in this selfish world, the one that never deserts him, the one that never proves ungrateful or treacherous, is his dog.  A man's dog stands by him in prosperity and poverty, in health and in sickness.  He will sleep on the cold ground when the wintry winds blow and the snow drives fiercely, if only to be near his master's side.  He will kiss the hand that has no food to offer, he will lick the wounds and sores that come in encounters with the roughness of the world.  He guards the sleep of his pauper master as if he were a prince.

When all other friends desert, he remains.  When riches take wing, and reputation falls to pieces, he is as constant in his love as the sun in its journey through the heavens.

If fortune drives his master forth, an outcast in the world, friendless and homeless, the faithful dog asks no higher privilege than that of accompanying him, to guard him against danger, to fight against his enemies.  And when that last scene of all comes, and death takes his master in its embrace and his body is laid away in the cold ground, no matter if all other friends pursue their way, there, by the graveside will the noble dog be found, his head between his paws, his eyes sad, but open in alert watchfulness, faithful and true, even in death.

Senator George Graham Vest, speaking to a jury about Old Drum, shot in 1869

Kabar - faithful and true, even in death.  May he rest in peace with his beloved master.